What Should You Know Before Hiring the Best Roofers in Effort, PA?
Hiring a roofer sounds simple… until you actually start looking. Suddenly, every company claims to be “the best,” every quote looks different, and you’re left wondering who’s honest and who’s ready to run off with your money. If you’re searching for the
Best Roofers in Effort, PA, or even planning a roof replacement in Stroudsburg, PA, you want someone who knows what they’re doing, not someone learning on your home.
And honestly, most homeowners don’t know what to look for. That’s not your fault. Roofing isn’t something you shop for every year. Most people only do it once or twice in their lifetime.
So, here’s a straight-up guide on what really matters before you sign anything.
1. Experience Actually Matters
A roofing company that’s been around for 5 years is fine. But a company that’s been around 71+ years? That’s a whole different level of trust. That usually means:
- They’ve handled every type of roof problem under the sun
- They’re not disappearing next month
- They’ve learned from decades of mistakes and improvements
- People in the area already know them by name
For example, Asch Poconos Roofing has been doing this since 1955. Three generations. That’s the type of history you want when hiring the “best” because longevity isn’t an accident. It’s earned.
2. Ask About the Materials
Some roofers talk a big game, but then use cheap shingles that curl up after the first hot summer. You want materials from brands that actually last, not bargain-bin “builder grade.”
A reliable roofer should be upfront about what they’re using. If they’re offering:
- Owens Corning
- Velux products
- Any branded, certified, warrantied materials
That’s a good sign. If they dodge the question or push something with no name? Red flag.
3. Compare Quotes… Seriously, Don’t Skip This Part
People get weird about quotes. Some feel guilty asking for multiple. Others feel rushed. Don’t. John Asch, from Asch Poconos Roofing, even encourages homeowners to get multiple quotes.
Why? Because:
- Prices vary a lot
- Some companies overcharge just because people don’t know better
- You want an apples-to-apples comparison
- You should feel comfortable with the people working on your home
If a roofer pressures you to “sign now before the price changes,” walk away. Quality contractors don’t use scare tactics.
4. Understand What’s Actually Included
A cheaper quote often means less included, and this is where homeowners get stuck paying more later.
Things you should always clarify:
- Does the price include tear-off?
- Are they installing underlayment and waterproofing?
- Are flashing and ventilation upgrades included?
- Does cleanup cost extra?
- Is the warranty written or just spoken?
A real professional lays everything out clearly. Asch Poconos Roofing even gives a guarantee, which is rare these days.
5. Communication Shouldn’t Feel Like Pulling Teeth
You should never have to chase your roofer for answers. If their office staff can’t even keep an appointment or return a phone call, imagine how the project will go.
Good roofing teams:
- Pick up the phone
- Call you back quickly
- Show up when they say they will
- Let you know what’s happening at every step
This might sound basic, but it’s honestly one of the biggest signs you hired the right people.
6. Don’t Pay Until the Work Is Actually Done
Some companies demand half upfront and then… disappear for three weeks. Or worse, the work begins, and suddenly you realize they’re cutting corners.
A trustworthy company doesn’t need all your money upfront. Asch Poconos Roofing, for example, doesn’t ask for a cent until the whole project is completed and you’re satisfied. That’s the kind of confidence you want from a roofer.
7. Look at Real Local Projects
This is where most homeowners get fooled. Any company can grab pretty pictures online and call them “their work.”
Instead, ask:
- Do you have photos of roof replacements in Effort, PA?
- Do you have Stroudsburg roof replacement projects I can see?
- Can you show before-and-after images?
- Any real customer testimonials?
Asch Poconos Roofing showcases multiple roof installations and tear-offs from Monroe, Northampton, and Pike Counties, which is the type of transparency you should expect.
8. Know the Difference Between “Repairs,” “Replacement,” and “Band-Aid Work.”
Some roofers will talk you into a full replacement even when you only need repairs. Others will fix tiny sections, knowing the roof will leak again soon, and you’ll have to call them back.
A good roofing contractor gives honest guidance:
- If you need a simple repair → they say so.
- If your roof genuinely needs a full replacement → they explain why.
- If there are multiple options → they help you compare.
Honesty is part of being “the best,” not just skill.
9. Storm Damage? Be Extra Careful Who You Hire
After storms, a lot of “pop-up roofers” suddenly appear in town. They knock on doors, offer cheap deals, promise fast fixes… and then vanish when problems start. Hiring a long-standing, local company protects you from all that mess.
Local = accountable.
10. Read Their Guarantee Carefully
Verbal guarantees mean nothing. You need something written, specific, and enforceable.
A strong roofing guarantee usually includes:
- Workmanship
- Materials
- Installation practices
- Duration (10-40 years, depending on shingles)
- Transferability if you sell your home
Asch Poconos Roofing is known for having one of the strongest written guarantees in Pennsylvania. That alone makes them stand out.
11. Choose Someone Who Treats Your Home Like Their Own
The roofing crew should be:
- Polite
- Careful with your landscaping
- Cleaning up nails and debris
- Respectful of your space
Roofing is messy. But it shouldn’t feel like a construction tornado rolled through your yard. A good crew handles the chaos so you don’t have to.
12. Bonus Tip: Don’t Wait Too Long
Waiting until your roof is really leaking is the fastest way to spend more money. Small issues become big issues fast: rotten wood, mold, insulation damage, and interior leaks. A quick inspection can save you thousands.
Final Thoughts
Hiring the right roofer isn’t complicated when you know what to look for. Look for experience, transparency, a written guarantee, and real professionalism. If you’re planning a roof replacement in Stroudsburg, PA, or searching for the Best Roofers in Effort, PA, take your time. Compare quotes. Ask real questions. And choose someone you genuinely trust.
And if you want the safest, simplest choice? Asch Poconos Roofing has over 71 years of proof that their work holds up.
Ready to work with a roofing company that actually keeps its promises?
FAQs
1. How do I choose the right company for a roof replacement in Stroudsburg, PA?
The first step towards narrowing down to a company to replace their roof in Stroudsburg, PA is to examine their experience, material, and written guarantees. You need somebody who has been in the business long enough to take ownership of his or her work. Never accept the first offer and inquire about cleaning off, tear-off and warranties. No questionable roofer will leave you in the dark trying to understand them.
2. Why would a roofing company be considered the best in Effort, PA?
The best is often a person who is local, trusted and consistent. The roofers at Effort, PA are expected to have more than flashy ads; they have to have years of service. When a roofer has good materials, talks well, and provides a good written promise, then that is some indication that this person is worth employing.
3. Should I obtain several roofing estimates and select a contractor?
Absolutely. Prices of roofs do not change as much as one would expect. Requesting more than one quote would guard you against overpaying, as well as help you know what is being captured. Good roofers do not hurry to make a decision and make you feel comfortable; it is necessary to compare. It is your house, your cash, and your decision.
4. What is the average duration to replace a roof?
95% of our roof replacements are finished in one day depending on the weather, size and complexity of the roof. An experienced professional is efficient, yet he or she does not hurry in making crucial decisions about information such as flashing, ventilation, and cleaning. In case your project is a bigger one or requires additional repairs, a contractor must be able to give you a clear schedule.
